The Criteria
- It has to be an indigenous variety
- It has to be in the $10 price range (this is Cheap Wine Ratings afterall)
- I have to be able to find it (duh !)
- I’d like to pick something that 4 other folks don’t pick
- It would be really nice if I could find an example of the varietal grown outside its native region for comparison
I considered several: Primitivo, Nero d’Avola, and Montepulciano d’Abruzzo to name a few but I felt it was just too likely that someone else would pick one of those. I also considered Aglianico, but the nativity of that varietal is questionable–it is believed to come from Greece. That said, I did pick up some bottles of each of those for some future tastings 😉
I finally made my choice, Negroamaro. But this choice is not without some controversy. Why?
- I had a hard time finding it and only ended up with two bottles to try.
- I absolutely couldn’t find an example of this grown outside its native region (I’d be surprised if it even exists). Oh well.
It’s rare to find a pure Negroamaro as it is typically blended with other varietals. I was lucky enough to find a “pure play” to include in this review. Typically, Negroamaro is blended with Malvasia Nera, Sangiovese or Montepulciano. I tried two examples of Negroamaro for this review, one pure and one blend. Both were enjoyable, earthy wines.
Pure Negroamaro
I found the Casa Catelli Negroamaro 2003 to be a pretty good, earthy wine. Although I think it could stand a couple more years of bottle age. I picked up four bottles and I think I’ll let the others sit for a while. The Casa Catelli has a very nice bouquet of tobacco, plums and currants. It has a good mouth feel. The palate is cherry, currants, leather, earth and pepper. It’s very smooth with a hint of smokiness in the finish. The numbers came out to an 88 and if I can find it at the right price, I’ll definately buy more.
Wine: Casa Catelli
Varietal: Negroamaro
Alcohol: 13.5%
Rating: 88
Negroamaro Blend
On to the tasting… To be specific, the wine I tasted is Taurino Salice Salentino Riserva 2001. The color doesn’t have the greatest depth and I was afraid the wine would have a thin palate, but I was pleasantly surprised. Cherries, herbs and leather on the nose. Plum, apricot and earthy flavors with a peppery finish. A nice, earthy, old-style Italian red. This is an intense wine with interesting character. I gave it an 86. At $11.99 it’s still an affordable wine and probably worth a try. But if I had to pick between the two I’d go with the Casa Catelli. I think it’s a better wine and you’ll save a couple bucks, so how can you go wrong.
Wine: Salice Salentino
Varietal: Negroamaro / Malvasia Nera Blend
Alcohol: 13.5%
Rating: 86